What to read next

Leave a comment

Sort by
  • newest
  • oldest
  • most voted
avatar

23 Comments on "Superweek For Indian Shipbuilding: After P15A Kolkata, Navy Gets 1st P28 ASW Corvette Tomorrow"

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

NSR says —

I think India should replace HAL officials with some of these design and management people so that there will rapid progress in aeronautical systems needed by IAF…

The performance of HAL,, and interaction between IAF and HAL is abyssymal, worst kind,….

I think HAL house cleaning of management and technical leaders is in urgent need and should be of highest priority..

On the other hand if India is producing CIWS system locally and installed on this ship, then it should be installed on INS Vikramaditya immediately and look for a good company to collaborate and get a more capable one later…

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

The texture of the ship looks a awkward? is it done purposefully or is it poor workmanship. I feel like the metal used is actually crumpled… It looks uneven…

looking forward to your inputs.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

GRSE build quality is worse then MDL kochi is the best. the sides of the ship look like a state st bus.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

Hey but why that smoke emitting chamber looks black outside,doesn't look nice.Has it been repainted before tomorrow handover.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

About the P28, this ship is still in their sea trials and the conning tower is already covered in soot.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

Mr Anon 10:58 PM – this is a SHIP. Conning towers are found in submarines. Get a life and gen up before commenting.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

Kochi is the worst when it comes to delivery and workmanship…look at plight of INS Vikrant one delay after another. This project was granted to Kochi purely due to push from A.K.Antony, the most useless Defense Minister in India's history after Krishna Menon.
The soot covering means this vessel has been tried and tested well before handing over to Indian Navy.
The "texture" of all warships are same on closer inspection, even the ones in the service of US or UK navies.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

No klub then on the ship ???

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

India should NOW get more submarines then surface ships, import them then building at home yards. china is way ahead of india in numbers and quality/weaponary.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

Anay naval armada no matter how efficient and powerful it is, is easy target without submarines. Get a dozen of Scorpions/Akula or whatever at the earliest to complement these surface ships.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

India should have a mix of indian Russian and european ships (surface/submarines). I am sure these indian ships have a high engine noise making them easy targets for subs. Also they have very little protection against asymmetrical threats like small terrorist boats packed with explosives.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

The problem is – india is building ships to send them on diplomatic missions, rescue and fighting pirates. There are very few ships that can actually deliver a punch to China in southern china sea. India just does not have the infrastructure to match the China numerically…so import more ships from israel and russia.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

i was told there is NO weapon on the ship, is that true?

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

@anon 12.22 PM,

there are several areas where Israel is the best, including EW, but i guess ships are not among them. Indian ship building is not all that bad, but when it comes to armament and electronics almost all are imported (which includes Israel)

Sreenivas R

Rohan
Guest
2 years 4 months ago
From observation of recent projects the Navy is too Pakistan focused to make any serious claim to being a global power. Why I say this? Quite simple…look at the AAW suite on all of the recent projects…there is no coherent approach to long range ship defense. Most vessels have been built without the kind of long range radar and combat management systems seen on the Kolkata. Even in the case of the Kolkata there is no weapon system capable of exploting the capability. LR-SAM with 70km range hardly counts as long range in world where the top of the line… Read more »
Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

To the guy who is saying kochi is the worst, just look at the pics of the vikrant, it looks like a western ship. AK antony is the only defense minister who has delayed the acquisition of western weapons favoring indigenous weaponry, he advanced kochi because that is a better place to build as it is out of reach of pak and china it also has a longer and better maritime history. with travancore being the only local power to defeat the dutch.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

Rohan

LR SAM is equivalent to aster 30 which is widely used by France, UK etc. Also much longer range 120 km SAM is also in development for P-15B, unlike whether it will fit in existing P-15A.

No SAM has over the horizon engagement capability let alone 200nm it is not possible, US is making that claim that SM-6 can engage target over the horizon (even then limited to less 60 km) but it is all on paper. Supposedly Barak-8 has over the horizon capability but IAI/DRDO are tight lipped about it.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

@Anon 7.44 PM

Any pic of Vikrant will show that even after so many years in the making and unlimited infusion of funds it's still half complete tub decked with flowers like a temple elephant.
There is one delay after another associated with this project. It's build quality will be apparent after it is complete.
Other shipyards are also out of reach of Pakistan and China. If the defense minister and secretary of defense is from south, all major defense contracts will go to southern firms. MDL is however immune to this phenomena. Worst victim is GRSE.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

Integral ASW chopper has not yet been a acquired for the corvettes. Nor do they have an active array towed sonar (still under development by DRDO). Not a complete ASW platform without these essential components; especially in the Indian Ocean.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

GRSE build quailty is like a bullock cart. Thank god it does not get much to do.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

The Keel of the vikrant was laid in 2009 and it has only been 5 yrs considering it is the firt effort kochi is making good time. Looks lime somebody thinks Groskov was in record time.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

The Keel of the vikrant was laid in 2009 and it has only been 5 yrs considering it is the firt effort kochi is making good time. Looks lime somebody thinks Groskov was in record time.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
2 years 4 months ago

these ships with isreal/russian/european electronics and weapons are a maintenance nightmare.

wpDiscuz

Copyright © . All rights reserved.